YahooSarah answers reader questions about compliance
Two weeks ago, we discussed how to stay compliant with the Yahoo! Publisher Network rules and regulations (What Not to Do: Tips from YahooSarah, July 19). Apparently that post was a big hit, drawing 30 comments. A number of you included questions among your comments, so we felt that we should further clarify a few things.
Several of you wrote to express thanks for articulating the rules, but you also reiterated the need for a system for reporting abuse. Well, we’ve got you covered: We announced a solution for that just a little while ago. To report abuse, use the link under “Network Feedback” link, at right.
There were a number of questions about Rule 4: “Don’t place images next to ads.” Some around the blogosphere speculate that if you put an image next to an Ad Unit that seems to have something to do with that ad, then it should be OK. For example, say you’ve targeted financial services and then place a dollar sign image next to the ad. Seems like that would be kosher, right? Nope! Our guidelines clearly state: Images or other media cannot be associated with the Ad Unit.
There are a number of reasons for this, but two stand out. One is traffic quality: Advertisers want their prospects to understand what they’re clicking on. Images can confuse the issue.
The second reason is brand control. Put yourself in the advertiser’s shoes: Would you want images associated with your brand that you had no control over?
With Regard to Rule 5, “Don’t block the crawler,” a reader noted that: “I do not [block the crawler], but sometimes they get trapped by my security routine… A while ago I asked for the IP ranges of the bots to protect them from being banned: someone replied to me that you do not disclose that kind of information. IMHO, spiders should obey robots.txt.”
It’s true: we don’t give that type of information out. We suggest, humbly, that you look into your security routine and try some different approaches to see what works best.
One reader asked about Rule 7: “Don’t manipulate our ad code.” This person asked if it were against our Terms of Service to change the ad code in order to, for example, get the background color from a variable as long as it doesn’t change the way the page renders.
The fact is, it’s part of your agreement with us that you won’t modify the Ad Unit in any way—Terms and Conditions, (4) (b) (i). Most publishers wouldn’t need to, as our Ad Setup offers every color of the rainbow and then some. I can see your issue, but rules are rules.
Rule 8, which addressed international traffic, drew this question: “We need to know if we still need to implement our own geotargeting or if Yahoo! Publisher Network will do it for us. On some SEO forums, someone says international clicks are not counted anymore. If we need to supply our own geo-targeting, then [you guys] should point publishers to geotargeting scripts or provide some.”
Rule 8 has more to do with who your audience is than about geotargeting solutions. If you target U.S. users with your content, you’ll find that U.S. users will come, and you, your users and our advertisers will mutually benefit. But if you feel you need a geotargeting solution, there are a number of third-party and open source geotargeting solutions out there. In fact, another reader made a suggestion about this in response to your comment. You can also do a quick search on Yahoo! Search to find more.
Inappropriate targeting, the subject of Rule 9, made one reader wonder why he sometimes sees ads for General Electric stocks on his cooking site, even though he uses appropriate targeting (food, appliances). The answer is that sometimes the ad inventory is not on hand to fill every niche, so we display what we call “run of network ads”.
Thanks, everyone, for your comments and suggestions! Keep ’em coming!
—YahooSarah